Labels vs. Purpose: Which One Is Steering?
Writing · Week 2 of 9
You are "the responsible one." Who decided that?
A label is a one word role, like the responsible one, that tells you what to do in advance. Purpose is the reason behind your actions, and it leaves you more choices.
This is the second of nine posts about the ways we let ourselves down without noticing, which I call the Nine Energetic Betrayals. This one is about the words we use to describe ourselves, and how a single word can quietly decide what we do next.
What a Label Does
A label is a one word costume. The breadwinner. The caregiver. The responsible one. The difficult one. The warm one. Labels are comforting because they tell us what to do before we have to think. They also box us in, because they hand us a script in advance.
One label I wear all the time is Good Father. Here is what it costs me. When I raise my voice or get frustrated with my kids, it falls outside how I see myself. That creates a gap inside me, and the gap makes me crankier and less of the father I want to be.
The same thing happens to anyone with a label. Someone who thinks of themselves as the warm one may struggle to be firm, even when a situation clearly needs it. The gap between who they believe they are and what the moment asks for can leave a quiet feeling of letting themselves down. Over time that feeling can turn into resentment or numbness, and neither one is easy to trace back to a word.
What Purpose Does
The big question is, what is the meaning of life? My answer is to make meaning out of your life. We make meaning by finding and following our Purpose. Labels only give you Purpose within a narrow band. To fully realize our potential, we have to seek Purpose in all areas of our life. A general idea of who you want to be gives you a goal and a way to reach it, and moving out of a label gives you flexibility. The things you care about might be hidden under the label, so it is good to sit down and question your labels once a year. Until you recognize and update them, you may not be able to see or understand your Purpose easily.
For me, Good Father protects me from having to do more work. It keeps me from looking at where I need to grow and change. That is why a label is an arrow to where the work is.
One person's Purpose may be creating safety and security. Another's may be care and inclusion for their family. Neither one belongs to a gender or a role. What matters is what sits underneath: whether what you do comes from what you care about, or from the costume.
Two Ways It Shows Up
Some of us wear labels like provider, protector and the strong one. Others wear labels like caregiver, peacemaker and the nice one. Either way, the label can become a place to hide. A provider may refuse help because asking feels like admitting something. A peacemaker may swallow a hard truth because saying it would break the label.
Underneath both is usually the same fear of being judged. If I am not this, what am I? As a result, many of us skip the ordinary tools in our own lives, such as asking for help or taking a break, because a label says we should not need them.
A Question for This Week
Notice one label you pin on yourself. Maybe it is the responsible one, the easygoing one, the good parent or the one who never needs anything. Then ask what that label is protecting. The answer shows you what you actually need in that moment. Knowing what it protects is what makes the work stick.
Goals to Think About
If you think this is one of your core betrayals, here are five goals to think about. The last two are micro goals. In January, we'll tie all of this together through our goal wizard to help you create really effective mini goals for 2027.
- I will name what I care about most in my work this year, in one plain word.
- Each week, I will catch one "I am the kind of person who" thought and ask what I actually want.
- I will spend one hour a month on something that matters to me and has no label.
- I will do one small thing today that is not "like me."
- I will introduce myself with something other than my job.
Common Questions
What is the difference between a label and a purpose?
A label is a fixed role handed to you. A purpose is what you care about underneath.
Are all labels bad?
No. Labels can be comforting and useful. They become a problem when they decide what you do before you have thought about the moment.
How do I find my purpose?
Start small. Pick a label you wear and ask what it is protecting. What it protects points to what you care about underneath. Your answer can change as you learn more about yourself.
About the Author
Jon B. Pease, LMFT (California LMFT #48823) is a licensed marriage and family therapist in West Los Angeles. He wrote the book behind this series. Learn more at JonPease.com.
Where to Go Next
Before you act this week, ask yourself: am I acting from care, or reacting from fear?
This post is general education. It is not therapy and it is not advice for your situation. If you are in crisis, call or text 988, or call 911.
The Nine Energetic Betrayals and the ideas and wording in these posts are original work by Jon B. Pease, LMFT. Please do not copy without permission.